American Idol contestant Haley Scarnato has gone from Haley who? to the season six version of Katherine McPhee. Last week our friends at TMZ reported that she wore McPhee's old hair extensions She's not in McPhee's league as a signer, but her flesh-baring, possible wardrobe malfunction inspired outfit for Tuesday's Top 11 performance show was well beyond anything McPhee could have pulled of last year in terms of skin. Why? Well for one she's not all doughy in the middle...

She's still got a long way to go to catch up to McPhee in terms of cleavage shots, but our Zapruder-like analysis of the video tape very clearly shows that Simon Cowell was a big fan of Haley's comets...

Even though Scarnato's outfit looked like wardrobe malfunction waiting to happen the HD caps below below show that the top appears to have safely glued to her body under the armpits. The HD pictures are below the jump...

You can download the performance from RapidShare...